Smoky the Cowhorse · Question
How does Smoky the Cowhorse develop the theme of Cruelty and Kindness?
Answer
Smoky the Cowhorse by Will James develops Cruelty and Kindness across the chapters the companion marks for this theme.
The narrative contrasts Clint's patient, gentle training with the brutal treatment Smoky endures as a rodeo outlaw and a livery horse, highlighting the impact of human nature on animals.
The thief's brutal beating of Smoky and constant torment contrasts sharply with Clint's earlier gentle handling, highlighting the theme of cruelty versus kindness.
The contrast between the crowd's cruel disappointment and the rider's gentle words to the 'has been' horse.
Tourists unknowingly mistreat Smoky through overwork, while the stable man shows small kindnesses like currying and feeding.
Evidence in the book
- XI: “The Feel of a Strange Hand”
The thief's brutal beating of Smoky and constant torment contrasts sharply with Clint's earlier gentle handling, highlighting the theme of cruelty versus kindness.
- XII: “When the Good Leaves”
The contrast between the crowd's cruel disappointment and the rider's gentle words to the 'has been' horse.
- A Many-Men Horse
Tourists unknowingly mistreat Smoky through overwork, while the stable man shows small kindnesses like currying and feeding.
