← All themes

The Coming of Bill · Theme

Individualism vs. Interference

How The Coming of Bill develops Individualism vs. Interference.

Characters like Bailey Bannister and Lora Delane Porter constantly meddle in others' lives, while Kirk and Ruth struggle to assert their own choices, illustrating the tension between personal freedom and well-meaning but destructive interference.

Where it surfaces

  • I: A Pawn of Fate

    Mrs. Porter's interference in Ruth's life and her plan to control Kirk's marriage contrasts with Kirk's independent, carefree attitude.

  • Ruth States Her Intentions

    Bailey tries to interfere in Ruth's personal choices, but Ruth asserts her own will and rejects his attempts to control her.

  • III: The Mates Meet

    Kirk values his freedom and bachelorhood, but Lora Delane Porter's interference and his own introspection lead him to question his solitary life.

  • IV: Troubled Waters

    Bailey's determination to control Ruth's choices and interfere in her relationship with Kirk clashes with Ruth's individual desires, while Mrs. Porter actively enables their independence.

  • Wherein Opposites Agree

    Bailey attempts to control Ruth's marriage, while Mrs. Porter and Ruth assert their independence.

  • VI: Breaking the News

    Ruth asserts her independence against her father's control, while Aunt Lora actively intervenes in the family dispute.

  • VIII: Suspense

    Kirk's struggle with his helplessness contrasts with the doctor's and Steve's attempts to intervene and manage his state of mind.

  • X: An Interlude of Peace

    Ruth and Kirk assert their independence from Aunt Lora's controlling advice, choosing their own way of life.

  • XII: A Climax

    Bailey's confrontation represents societal interference in Kirk's life, challenging his romanticized self-image and forcing him to confront his responsibilities.

  • II: An Unknown Path

    Kirk resents the 'gospel of Lora Delane Porter' and the restrictions it imposes on his son Bill, feeling that his individuality and family life are being encroached upon.

  • V: The Real Thing

    Kirk resents Lora's rules and Ruth's abdication of responsibility, feeling his son's spirit is being stifled by excessive regulation.

  • VII: Cutting the Tangled Knot

    Bailey's meddling in Ruth's life and Kirk's attempt to impose domesticity clash with Ruth's desire for autonomy and her resistance to authority.

  • VIII: Steve to the Rescue

    Steve decides to interfere directly by kidnapping the child, believing a 'jolt' will restore order, contrasting with Mrs. Porter's detached eugenic planning.

  • IX: At One in the Morning

    Steve's clandestine plan to remove William from the Porter household represents a direct challenge to the interference of Mrs. Porter's system, asserting the child's right to a less regulated life.

  • X: Accepting the Gifts of the Gods

    Kirk and Steve act independently against the wishes of Ruth and Mrs. Porter, asserting their own vision for William's upbringing.

  • Mr. Penway on the Grill

    Mrs. Porter's relentless interrogation of Mr. Penway and her plans to track Kirk highlight the tension between personal freedom and external control.

  • Pastures New

    Steve's spontaneous, unplanned expedition and his rejection of Lora's rules embody a clash between personal freedom and external control.

  • Mrs. Porter's Waterloo

    Mrs. Porter's attempt to control Ruth's life and Kirk's defiance of her interference.

  • XVI: The White-Hope Link

    Lora Delane Porter's retirement from interference is a key turning point, allowing Kirk to reclaim his own life and choices.