The Old Wives’ Tale
Free public-domain edition — preview in your browser, no account required for the first chapter.
Preview free · sign up to save progress, download to your shelf, and sync with the apps
Already have an account? Sign in
Read this masterful novel for its profound, unsentimental exploration of how time shapes women’s lives, and for its vivid portrait of a changing England.
Edition details
Book Summary
This novel traces the divergent lives of the Baines sisters, Constance and Sophia, from their youth in a provincial English drapery shop through old age. Constance embraces domestic stability, while Sophia elopes to Paris, facing hardship and independence. Their stories explore the inexorable passage of time and the weight of choices.
The Old Wives’ Tale follows Constance and Sophia Baines, daughters of a widowed draper in Bursley. Constance is steady and domestic, marrying the mild Samuel Povey and inheriting the shop. Sophia is rebellious, defying her mother to become a teacher before eloping with the charming but unreliable Gerald Scales to Paris. There, she endures abandonment, illness, and poverty before building a successful pension, amassing wealth but living alone. After decades, Sophia returns to Bursley, where the sisters reunite in old age. Constance cares for Sophia until her sudden death, then lives quietly, reflecting on the decline of their world. The novel juxtaposes provincial stability with worldly experience, examining marriage, motherhood, and the irreversible nature of life’s choices. It culminates in Constance’s own death, closing a cycle of endurance and change.
Reading guide
Go deeper in The Old Wives’ Tale
Character guides, themes, chapter companions — plus Character Web, narrative arc, and theme heatmap teasers that unlock fully beside the text in BetterReads.
Narrative arc
Story tension across the book.
- Setup
Sophia Baines
Sophia chafes against the decorum of her mother's house, where even a wagonette departure becomes a public ceremony and daughters are managed like stock. Quick, proud, and secretly contemptuous of the settled futures laid out for her, she notices everything and forgives little. Her elopement with the charming commercial traveller Gerald Scales splits the novel's world in two and sets the measure against which her sister's quieter life will be read.
Constance Baines
Constance bends her head over the baby and the ledgers alike, the steady centre of a household that has lost its matriarch and its runaway daughter at once. Her love for Samuel Povey is real but decorous, conducted in whispers and cutting-out rooms, and her mother's silent refusal to acknowledge it leaves her quietly exposed. She carries the Baines name into middle age, and the novel's long middle belongs to her endurance.
Gerald Scales
Gerald Scales arrives in Bursley as a bright smile and a lively gesture, the sort of man a shopgirl is warned against and a proud daughter cannot resist. He is irreclaimably a fool and a prodigy of irresponsibleness, resentful of his wife's height and her dignity, ready to suggest she write home for money. His weakness is the engine of Sophia's long exile, and his presence haunts the novel even when he is absent from it.
Mrs. Baines
Mrs. Baines presides over the Square with the correctness of a woman who has buried a husband and intends to bury the old order on her own terms. She manages Constance's romance by silence and Sophia's by vigilance, and her refusal to acknowledge what she sees is both a strategy and a fatigue. When she leaves the shop for Axe, her departure is the hinge on which the sisters' separate fates swing.
Samuel Povey
Samuel Povey rises from assistant to son-in-law to proprietor, a man of small body and large, easily wounded vanity, capable of black and terrible furies when jealous. He loves Constance with a sensitive, tyrannic conscience, and he loves the shop with something closer to religion. His Annual Sale poster is the first crack in Mrs. Baines's old order, and his fussing devotion carries the family through its long decline.
Mr. Critchlow
Mr. Critchlow has watched the Baineses through births, deaths, and elopements, dispensing pills and unwelcome opinions from behind his counter with equal indifference. He is the town's memory and its acid, a man who teases and is not teased, and whose dry verdicts carry more weight than anyone admits. His late marriage to Maria closes one of the novel's long, quiet loops and confirms how thoroughly the old generation has settled into its endings.
Passage of Time and Aging
The novel traces the lives of Constance and Sophia Baines from youth to old age, emphasizing the gradual, often unnoticed physical and psychological changes that transform young girls into 'old wives,' as inspired by the author's encounter with a grotesque old woman in a Paris restaurant.
Provincial Life vs. Worldly Experience
Constance remains in the insular, stable world of Bursley's St. Luke's Square, while Sophia escapes to Paris, experiencing adventure, hardship, and moral complexity, highlighting the contrast between domestic security and the wider, often harsher, world.
Marriage and Domesticity
The book explores different forms of marriage: Constance's steady, conventional union with Samuel Povey and Sophia's disastrous, passionate elopement with Gerald Scales, examining the realities of compromise, disappointment, and the constraints of domestic roles.
Social Class and Respectability
The Baines family's drapery business anchors them in the middle class, and the narrative constantly engages with the pressures of maintaining respectability, propriety, and social standing, particularly through characters like Mrs. Baines and the reactions to Sophia's flight.