One of Ours · Question
How does One of Ours develop the theme of Class and Social Mobility?
Answer
One of Ours by Willa Cather develops Class and Social Mobility across the chapters the companion marks for this theme.
The novel examines class distinctions in rural America, from the wealthy Wheelers to the struggling hired men. Claude's discomfort with his family's status and his admiration for the cultured Erlichs highlight his desire for a different kind of life, one defined by intellect and refinement rather than mere wealth.
Claude's discomfort with his family's frugality and his awareness of social expectations, as well as Leonard Dawson's success despite lack of formal education.
Claude initially mistakes the Erlichs' rich lifestyle for wealth, but learns they are poor yet know how to live, challenging his assumptions about class and happiness.
Claude's discomfort with formal dinner attire and the Erlichs' social circle highlights class distinctions, while Madame Schroeder-Schatz's advice on acquiring land suggests aspirations for upward mobility.
Evidence in the book
- II
Claude's discomfort with his family's frugality and his awareness of social expectations, as well as Leonard Dawson's success despite lack of formal education.
- VI
Claude initially mistakes the Erlichs' rich lifestyle for wealth, but learns they are poor yet know how to live, challenging his assumptions about class and happiness.
- Chapter: X
Claude's discomfort with formal dinner attire and the Erlichs' social circle highlights class distinctions, while Madame Schroeder-Schatz's advice on acquiring land suggests aspirations for upward mobility.
- XIV
Dan's commentary on property and labor highlights the class divide between landowners and hired men.
- XVI
Bayliss's criticism of the Erlichs' business and his courtship of Gladys, who is poor but stylish, reflect class dynamics and the pursuit of social standing.
- XIX
The contrast between the Wheelers' farm wealth, the Royces' millhouse, and the Farmers' modest cottage underscores class distinctions and the pressure of poverty.
- VI
Gladys reflects on how successful men like Bayliss control opportunities, limiting those with imagination.
- IX
The power dynamics between the Chief Steward and the officers highlight class tensions and corruption within the military hierarchy.
